Balancing Rewards and Punishment

Balancing Rewards and Punishment

Is caning the answer to the drop of discipline in schools? This article suggests that discipline actually begins at home where parents must balance discipline and rewards for best results.


PLAYING: Balancing Rewards and Punishment

7 min read

There have been talks again recently about bringing back caning to schools. Arguments from both sides are being floated about whether it is an effective form of punishment.  This is a rather delicate issue and needs to be handled carefully.  However, the proponents and opponents do agree on one thing, that the level of discipline among the young ones has somewhat dropped, contributing to the increasing cases of disruptive behaviours in schools.

Like many other things, discipline does begin at home. Before blaming other parties, parents must first evaluate their approach at home.  Are they being too strict or too lenient?  Is there a basic rule for the little ones to live by? Are they being fairly rewarded and punished?  Are their parenting actions effective?



These are some of the tough questions confronting parents today.  In all aspects of life, we want our actions to be effective.  We want to see positive results in whatever we do, including disciplining our kids.  Unfortunately, many parents succumb to their emotions along the way.  They are inconsistent in their rewarding and punishing their kids.  If they are in a good mood that day, they can overlook many glaring mistakes.  But if their moods are bad, a tiniest error can turn their home upside down.

Such parenting styles will never be effective because the children will be left confused.  They may not be able to differentiate between right and wrong because it all depends on the parents’ emotional state.

For the kids to understand and learn, their rewards and punishment must be consistent and rational.  We are all emotional creature, so to be rational in times of great distress is rather difficult.  Therefore, parents must find a way to ensure that they have a good reference and guide that will provide the needed consistency in dealing with their kids.

Fortunately, there have been many workable methods to achieve this state.  Some parents have used “points system” where good behaviours and performances will earn the kids valuable points.  On the contrary, any violations will result in point’s deductions.  Though this sounds like a lot of work, it is hard to deny its effectiveness.


The effectiveness of any methods used can only materialize if it is agreed and accepted by the kids.  A very smart way to achieve this state is to through mutual discussions by getting the whole family involved.  Create a safe environment for everyone to share their opinions, feelings and needs without any prejudgement and hidden agendas.  Even the little ones, as early as four, can get involved.  We will be surprised at their demands and desires.  Chances are, we will be left smiling and even more motivated to honour them.

For something like this to work, it has to be a two-way process. If parents choose to walk on a one-way street where only parental needs and demands are important, chances are it will be a lonely and hazardous street.  On the other hand, parents who chose to travel on a two-way street will find that their journey is a much more pleasant, calm and even exciting.

We all can be on this happy street.  All we need to do is to ask them to do what we want while committing ourselves to deliver what they need.  Through the mutual discussions, sincerely open your heart and give them the access.  Dig deep to understand their true needs and pledge to honour them.  This powerful action would prove too much for our kids to resist.  In return, they will provide us with their utmost cooperation and commitment to be the best they can be.


Once we are able to come up with such a fair system, we will find that kids will do their best to achieve the pre-agreed rewards while avoiding the punishments.  Clear rewards are such a motivating factor.  They don’t have to be expensive materials or gadgets; just sincere words of appreciation coupled with a warm hug will do.  Once in a while, treat them to a nice meal for a job well done.  On a really special occasion, a more valuable gift can be offered if they deserve it.   At other times, it’s the thoughts that count and kids are not expecting much more.  

But if a punishment, including the physical one, is necessary, they would gladly take it knowing that it is done in the fairest and most rational manner.  Instead of animosity, kids will learn to accept the consequences of their behaviours positively.  The effects may be gone after a few days but the lessons stay for life.

Such is the power of a clear rewards and punishment system.  If done well, we may be able to kiss the dreaded rotan a goodbye.

Zaid Mohamad is a Certified Parental Coach and the bestselling author of Smart Parents, Brighter Kids and Smart Parents, Richer Kids.  Log on to or write to him at


Disclaimer: This content is shared for informational purposes only and not intended to be a substitute for professional/medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. We recommended that you always seek the advice of your healthcare professional for any questions you may have regarding a medical condition/specific situation.


Recommended content


Nutritional Deficiencies in Children

Did you know that nutritional deficiencies in children are not uncommon but they are often overlooked?


Fueling Child Growth With Nutrient Rich Foods

Did you know that healthy food for kids is essential to support a child's growth and learning?


13 Fun and Effective Goal Setting Activities for Kids to Sharpen their Learning Abilities

Your child’s ability to set and achieve goals will determine their learning experience in school. Teaching your child effective goal setting activities will help them perform better amongst their peers because they are capable of prioritizing important tasks.

Mother with kids

What is an entrepreneurial mindset? And why you should develop it in your child?

Unlocking the Entrepreneurial Mindset: Empowering Your Child's Potential for Success! Discover the transformative power of an entrepreneurial mindset and why it's a crucial skillset to foster in your child.


11 Unexpected Ways Your Child Learn from Being Outdoors

Outdoor learning can be simply defined as experiential learning in, for, or about the outdoors. The philosophies and theories about outdoor education tends to emphasize the effect of natural environments on human beings, the educative role of stress and challenge, and experiential learning.


What Are Executive Function Skills And Why Are They Important For Children To Learn?

Executive Function is a set of mental skills that include working memory, flexible thinking, and self-control. In your child’s early years, it is vital that they learn how to craft these skills as it will determine how they operate in the future. Children facing problems with their executive function may have trouble with focusing, handling their emotions and following directions.

Family high five

Nature and Nurture: Why both are important in raising an exceptional child

Unlocking the Potential: The Dynamic Interplay of Nature and Nurture in Nurturing an Exceptional Child